My name, for those of you that don’t know it, is Alfred Darryl Moton, Jr. I’m named for my father (that’s him on the left) who was, in turn, named for his uncle Alfred, and the legendary film producer Darryl Zanuck. Family tradition on his side stipulates that the eldest son is named for the father; my paternal grandfather (he’s the guy standing next to my dad)’s name was McKinley Matthew Moton II. Or was it “Jr.?” I can never remember these things. Anyway, Dad’s the second-oldest son, my Uncle McKinley being “MMMIII,” as it were. The Moton family is, as I’ve discovered over the past couple of years, very, very large; that, combined with the general traditions within the family, should have lent itself to my realizing just how common my name could conceivably be.
But, I’m getting ahead of myself.
My best friend Steven is a sixty-something, twice-divorced guy with an un-ironic moustache, a voice deeper than God’s impression of James Earl Jones singing Barry White covers, and one of the most adept analytical minds I’ve ever met. We used to meet once a week for dinner and conversation; back when we worked together at a higher-ed nonprofit, we used our weekly sessions for the kind of emotional decompression only the most like-minded can truly experience. I doubt he’d particularly mind if I said there was something of a mentor/protegé-esque dynamic to our relationship; indeed, in many contexts, he’s provided me with the kind of advice I’d sought from, for instance, my dad.
I mention Steven only because one of his defining quirks is his attention-to-detail when it comes to the connections between things. Just as my neurotic trivial memory conjures up the connections between albums, comics, books, films, and other useless miscellany, Steven’s good at picking up on the things that happen in his life that draw threads between major events, and–more importantly–he’s good at picking up on the significance of the connections. In the words of my fictional nicknamesake, he “reads between the crumbs” to an extent I could only dream of being able to.
Like I said, Steven has served in a function long-abandoned by my biological father who, try though he might, doesn’t really do much in the way of fathering since I aged past the age at which his ass-whoopings were a viable threat. For as much as I want to love my father, our relationship…well, it sucks. It sucks, in a way that makes me bristle with something approaching disgust from the realm of vicious anger when I see my cousins talk about how fantastic their relationship with him is now that he’s jettisoned my mother in favor of his new wife. I try to say all of this without bitterness, although most of you reading this know I probably want to love my dad more than I actually do, but it’s easy to really look at all the interactions my dad has with his families, new and old, in his new life, and remember all the times I failed to be even visible to him over the years. It set the tone for a lot of what I’ve done with my life, relationship-wise.
It’s funny; whenever my dad does some stupid, fucked-up thing, my first reaction is to draw upon our connection–not only that we’re related by blood, but also that we’re exactly alike in so many ways, and completely unintentionally at that. It makes the fact that we have the same name all the more fitting, telling, and tragic, and so I often use that as the basic yardstick, imploring him sarcastically to “stay classy, namesake.”
It feels weird to bring this up as a means of bringing up what I’m about to bring up, but I mention all of this because it’s easy to get caught up in how frustrating my relationship with my father is, and how much I feel like I’ve missed out upon because of whatever reason (the actual reason isn’t important anymore). I can think of so many times in my life when I remember my dad doing some serious, nurturing, good-natured, actual bonding activities with people, it’s usually with other people’s kids. (No, I haven’t forgotten him taking Matt Corones–a kid two years older than I–to see Public Enemy when they played my hometown. They wouldn’t play my home state until long after I’d left. If nothing else, I deserve to be bitter about that. I still haven’t seen them.) Having such an association of disconnect and dysfunction with one’s father, even if it’s nowhere near as bad as some other folks’, still hurts, and cuts.
It’s particularly painful when you don’t really see much meaning, value, or point to your own life as an adult. I think about dying a lot (as anyone who knows me surely knows), and it’s vexing, not wanting to live, yet living out of fear of not living. It sounds cheap and suburban–and, fuck, maybe it is, I’m man enough to admit that much–but the emptiness of my current existence causes everything to reverberate the moment it passes through, and even the dead weight of my father’s general disengagement rings as clearly as a fucking bell.
Out of boredom, the other day, I googled my name, and was surprised to find the number of Alfred Motons out there. I’d done it a couple times before in the past, turning up a guy playing college football for some small school in Texas; didn’t expect to find much.
Hopefully, you all can understand my surprise when, as the first result, I read that Alfred Moton Jr. died last year, right around this time. Not only that, but he was shot to death, tragically (as if a shooting death is ever anything but tragic), by Alfred Moton Sr.
I’m not ashamed to admit that my mind immediately flashed to the American Splendor monologue:
The idea that, for eighteen years, there was another Alfred Moton Jr., a guy who had his own nicknames, thoughts, identity, everything–but still tied to both his name, and the name of the man who helped gave him life, was mind-fuck enough. To know that this Alfred Moton Jr. had an equally contentious relationship with his father wasn’t entirely out-of-the-question, as young men have issues with their fathers these days.
But knowing that this Alfred Moton Jr. was dead–and, not only was he dead, but he was dead at the hand of this other Alfred Moton, the one that gave him his life, and his name–that shook me. I went to Alfred Jr.’s facebook page, or tried to; there was only a year-old tribute page full of pictures with a light-skinned brother with a bright smile and telltale signs of the same youthful energy that makes every kid beautiful. He’s a kid,, I thought, and felt the lump form in my throat. He was a kid.
Was.
I remember what I felt like at that age, barely 18, attacking college with an enthusiasm I never thought I could attack anything with. I remembered meeting Langely, and Muhammad, and finally getting to hold Cori close and kiss her and our own stupid, sincere, ill-fated pledge to each other, and learning how to play music and that weird, apocryphal, incomprehensibly joyous confusion that is learning how to be in a band. And then I thought of everything that happened after that, Jordan and Jen, Danielle and April and Allie–Allison, the great love, all the great loves, all of which I carry to this fucking day, and remember how all of that kicked into gear when I was barely 18. It was the only time I can say unqualifiably that I wanted to live, and I knew that’s how Alfred must have felt then, that’s all anyone that age feels is a desire, an aching, a burning need to just be.
He could have been the one who made it, the one who made such a name for himself that people would hear the name “Alfred Moton” and think of something special, something significant, something that would make me smile with a bizarre sense of pride and say “that young guy stole my name,” only with a winking sense of glee, because I’d be sharing something beautiful with someone wonderful.
But that’s not going to happen. Because Alfred Moton had a shitty relationship with his father, who was a damaged man capable of horrible things, and because of that Alfred Moton, Alfred Moton Jr. doesn’t get to do anything other than be a sad story of tragic loss, the memory of a friend, brother, boyfriend, student, cousin, grandson, and son who was taken from the world before he should have been.
It’s illogical, irrational, and maybe even a bit selfish, but I feel a sense of loss, kind of like what Pekar said. I never knew Alfred Moton Jr., or the father who gave and then took his life, but I feel a kinship with both men. I wish I knew them. I wish they weren’t gone. I wish they were everything I wish my father and I were, because the world needs more fathers and sons, names and namesakes, that actually act like family.
I miss them, if that’s possible, or at least I miss what they could have been.
Just a thought.